There’s so much unprecedented about Physician Who’s newest regeneration, the place outgoing Time Lord Jodie Whittaker, the collection’ first feminine Physician, remodeled into returning star David Tennant’s 14th Physician. However one explicit tweak was carried out as a result of… properly, frankly some folks suck.

Each regeneration we’ve seen on Physician Who up so far has concluded with the brand new face of the Physician nonetheless wandering round within the costume of their predecessor for a bit—it’s a standard side of the handover, a reminder of the period that got here earlier than as a brand new one begins. “The Energy of the Physician,” nonetheless, did one thing very totally different for its unprecedented regeneration marking the return of David Tennant as a completely new incarnation of the Physician, somewhat than a return of his identification because the tenth Physician. As Jodie Whittaker’s Time Lord burned with transformative power, so did her outfit, changing it with the costume to be worn by Tennant in subsequent 12 months’s trio of sixtieth anniversary specials.

On the one hand, this doubtlessly comes throughout as dismissive of Whittaker’s tenure, so rapidly erased that even this visible custom couldn’t be given to her time because the Physician for the sake of the shock and awe of some of the in style actors to carry the function returning. However, talking within the newest problem of Physician Who Journal, returning showrunner Russell T Davies defended the choice as not simply protecting of Whittaker herself, however the truth that Physician Who is made on an island of depressing folks who haven’t precisely been pleasant to the concept of gender identification and drag efficiency currently.

“I used to be very sure that I didn’t need David to look in Jodie’s costume. I believe the notion of males dressing in ‘girls’s garments’, the notion of drag, could be very delicate. I’m an enormous fan of that tradition and the dignity of that, it’s really a worthwhile factor, but it surely must be carried out with immense thought and respect,” Davies—an brazenly and unabashedly queer man—informed DWM. “With respect to Jodie and her Physician, I believe it may appear like mockery when a straight man wears her garments. To place an important massive six-foot Scotsman into them appears like we’re taking the mickey.”

Davies was in significantly aware of the response from the British press, which is notedly dominated by bigoted, transphobic rhetoric—but it surely’s additionally truthful to say the choice was possible additionally made partly with Physician Who’s rising worldwide viewers because it expands to Disney+ subsequent 12 months, particularly in markets just like the U.S., the place right-wing bigots have made drag performers a goal in anti-LGBTQ tradition battle actions this 12 months. “If [the press] can play with gender in a sarcastic or essential manner, they’ll,” Davies continued. “We might have the Physician dressed as a knight, or dressed as God, or dressed as William Hartnell, and the one photograph they’d print could be of David in what they thought-about to be girls’s garments.”

It’s a disgrace that such narrow-minded cruelty has robbed Physician Who of this conventional handover, however not less than Davies is prepared to protect followers who might’ve been focused or triggered by seeing the present mired in bigoted “controversy” in the event that they’d gone via with it.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to count on the most recent Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the things you could learn about James Cameron’s Avatar: The Manner of Water.